Bhikkhuni Tide

Theravada Buddhism is perceived to be male dominated. In fact this view is not quite accurate: Theravada Monasteries are male dominated. As for the practise, the meditation, the inspiration, the women play a huge role.

There is little that women can’t do in Theravada. The only activity they cannot lead are the ordination of monks, and a couple of other technical areas for monks who have committed offences against the Vinaya rules (and likewise Bhikkhunis look after their own offence procedures). Otherwise there are no doctrinal bars.

Women can meditate, and teach meditation. They can give precepts and refuges. They can open centres. They can become enlightened.

The word ‘doctrinal’ is italicised for a reason though; there are some cultural perceptions about the role of women in Thai Buddhism that have no doctrinal basis.

For instance there are some temples in the North of Thailand that bar women from certain stupas. These places are rather few compared to the vast number of temples. And quite where they get this idea from is hard to imagine. The Buddha specifically allowed stupas to be built as an inspiration, pilgrimage and demonstration of faith in the teaching. There was no mention of being for one sex only. It’s a real shame that these temples have gotten such ideas.

There is also a common idea that women can’t become enlightened. Perhaps this stems from another doctrinal error – that only ordained monastics can become Arahants. This traditional error likely comes from a further fallacy, that when one becomes enlightened, one either ordains as a monk/nun or else will pass away within 7 days – presumably because they have little means of supporting themselves. This too has no doctrinal basis.

However the idea came about it is wrong – according to the suttas, men, women, ordained and lay can become enlightened. Many Thais in fact highly venerate some Mae Chees as being arahants. Many Thais revered female lay Abhidhamma teacher Ajahn Naeb as being fully enlightened. So the views in Thailand are hardly consistent.

In fact there are many wrong views floating about any Buddhist community – the scriptures are vast and not many people have read them all. (And those that have still disagree)

The Monastery

The male domination of the monasteries came about not by design, or by sexism, but by the simple fact that the female ordained lineage fizzled out. With no nuns to ordain new nuns, that left the poor men to endure the hardships of the renunciate and celibate  life …. ok, so that was a bit bias. But the fact remains – the monastic structure was such that it required a quorum of nuns to ordain new nuns, and when there are too few left there will be no more ordinations. The same would be true if there were not enough men.

For instance in the early days of Buddhism in New Zealand, Australia and Europe, Westerners who wanted to be ordained there had to fly in monks from Asia in order to have enough to make a full quorum.

So

So there is little that a woman cannot do in Theravada Buddhism according to the doctrine. If culturally a particular society has a set or perceptions limiting either sex in any way – that is a matter of that society.

Recently there have been Bhikkhunis ordaining again in Theravada Buddhism. Whether one considers their lineage to be authentic or not is almost a moot point. They are here, they are ordaining, they are the future :- and the sangha/society has to get behind them or get left behind.

Advertisements

About Cittasamvaro

Auto blogography of an urban monk
This entry was posted in All Posts, Bhikkhuni issue. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Bhikkhuni Tide

  1. Rebecca says:

    Dear Bhante
    I am glad to hear that you seem to be in support of women’s practice in Theravada and the revival of the bhikkhuni order. Would you be able to outline exactly what you are planning on personally doing to help bring this about?

  2. tyler says:

    satu! satu! satu!

  3. Illuminés says:

    There’s no need for you to outline anything, dear Venerable. Just keep doing what you’re doing 🙂 Sadhu for your practice and sadhu for your support. Sabba mangalam.

  4. Kondanna says:

    Great to hear further support for bhikkhunis. This is refreshin as I came here just 5 minutes after reading about the galling going-ons at another sangha :
    http://sujato.wordpress.com/2011/03/23/bswa-presidents-report-on-being-sent-to-coventry/

  5. Rebecca says:

    Dear Illumines – I would appreciate it if you would refrain from trying to censor my comment. I am sure Bhante is capable of answering my question himself – this is somewhat obstructed by your attempts to deflect him away from it. I had hoped that this was a free and open space and that questions were therefore permitted’.

  6. Cittasamvaro says:

    Thanks for your comments.
    I refrained from giving my personal views – to make the point that the arrows of change are pointing in one direction, and those who don’t adapt with this will be left behind.
    Just like the sky knows no East or West, I don’t see a need to form fixed positions. I just try to treat people respectfully and always encourage dharma in any way I can.
    I’m glad to welcome Bhikkhuni Suvijjana and am sure our community here will enjoy the short time we have with her.

Comments are closed.